They're totally different right?

I got this coat in December at Forever 21. I think it's really cute & I love that it's long & has pockets.

I went & got this coat below, in January. Hubs was with me when I bought it & saw it in the bag & said it was exactly the same as the other 1. Men. It's totally different right? The top 1 is suppose to be suade & the bottom 1 is suppose to be leather. The top 1 is lighter & has buttons & the bottom 1 has a hood & a zipper.